Sports And Education While Research Has Shown Essay

Length: 8 pages Sources: 7 Subject: Sports Type: Essay Paper: #14018301 Related Topics: College Sports, Sports, Sport, Sport Injury
Excerpt from Essay :

Sports and Education

While research has shown that participating in high school sports has a positive correlation with academic performance, these studies have missed key details regarding high school sports programs, thus skewing the results and portraying sports as far more beneficial for academic and personal success than the evidence actually dictates. Furthermore, these problems are exacerbated when carried into college, and a review of the literature regarding both high school and college sports programs reveals that sports are less effective at encouraging education and carry far more negative side-effects than other comparable, non-athletic extracurricular activities.

When addressing the possible academic contribution of high school and college sports, it is important to investigate not only whether or not sports contribute to education, but whether or not they contribute to education more or less than other comparable extracurricular activities, and furthermore, whether or not sports carry with them attendant negative side-effects not seen with other extracurricular activities.

With this in mind, the investigation of sports and their effects on education undertaken in this study revealed that while high school sports do correlate with educational benefits for those students who participate in them, these benefits are not necessarily any greater than those provided by other extracurricular activities, and furthermore, that high school sports carry the additional risk of injury and an increased proclivity for violence (especially for football players and wrestlers) that is non-existent in other extracurricular activities. For college sports, research reveals that while student athletes entering college will likely have worse academic profiles than their peers, over time these differences begin to disappear, although the pervasive problems with commercialization as well as ethnic and gender discrimination inflict side-effects not necessarily reflected in academic scores. Thus, while one may comfortably state that on the whole sports do contribute to education, when weighed against the potential for harm this contribution may ultimately be minimal, at least when compared to other extracurricular activities.

In any attempt to determine whether or not sports contribute to the education of high school and college students, one must be wary of asking the proper questions and proceeding in a careful manner in order to ensure the accuracy of one's conclusions, especially because the issue can occasionally become heated. Thus, before proceeding into a review of the extant literature regarding the subject, it is worthwhile to briefly consider some of the most frequently cited arguments for and against school sports, as well as those arguments in favor of extracurricular activities in general. The most commonly cited for the latter is the suggestion that extracurricular activities enable "youths to socialize with peers and adults, set and achieve goals, compete fairly, recover from defeat, and resolve disputes peaceably," as well as offering youths the opportunity "to form new connections with peers and acquire social capital [and] in addition, extracurricular activities are one of the few contexts in which adolescents regularly come in contact with unrelated adults outside of the classroom" (Darling, Caldwell, & Smith, 2005, p. 52). These benefits hold true across the board for extracurricular activities, except where certain activities actually encourage division and escalation of conflict (a topic that will be addressed later on).

For those advocating school sports as best or ideal amongst extracurricular activities, the most frequently stated benefits are the practical lessons in teamwork provided and the maintenance of physical health, coupled with research suggesting sports correlate with an increase in average grade as well as reducing the likelihood of students' using drugs or alcohol (research that must be viewed with a grain of salt and placed in a much larger context, as will be discussed later). For those against, school sports represent a misallocation of resources towards extracurricular activities which only provide some of the benefits of such activities while carrying with them unacceptable risks, such as physical injury and a subservience to peer pressure and the need to conform as a result of the team's well-being being placed above the individual's. Both positions may be validated by

...

A 1994 longitudinal study examining 10th graders in comparison to their "student background and 8th grade measures of the dependent variables" found "positive effects of sport participation on grades" alongside other developmental benefits such as improved "self-concept, locus of control and educational aspirations" alongside "a negative effect on discipline problems" (Fejgin, 1994, p. 211). Although there are certain extenuating factors which serve to complicate these results, this essay will proceed through the rest of the literature regarding the effects of high school sports on academic success before pointing out these criticisms (especially because the majority of the literature comes to the same conclusions as Fejgin's article, and suffers from many of same biases, or at least, omissions).

In their research article "Extracurricular school activities: The good, the bad, and the nonlinear," Marsh and Kleitman (2002) studied twelve-grade students in order to determine the effects of extracurricular schools activities (ESAs) on academic performance. The researchers found, like the Fejgin study, that participation in sports had positive effects on "school grades, coursework selection, homework, educational and occupational aspirations, self-esteem, freedom from substance abuse, number of university applications, [and] subsequent college enrollment" (p. 464). This coincides with a more recent article written by Darling, Caldwell, and Smith (2005) which found that "adolescents who participated in ECAs reported higher grades, more positive attitudes toward schools, and higher academic aspirations once demographic characteristics and prior adjustment were controlled" (p. 51). However, both the Marsh and Kleitman research and the Darling et. al. article had importance differences both from the Fejgin's conclusions and each other, and examining these differences and nuances helps to reveal some of the problems which arise when attempting to study the effects of sports in this way.

Firstly, where the Fejgin article studied only the effects of sports on academics and other factors, the latter two articles examined sports alongside a large number of other possible extracurricular activities, finding unequivocally that sports do not provide the same robust improvement in academic and personal development as other, non-athletic activities (although in both cases, this fact is somewhat buried in the results and the authors do not other to spend much time considering its implications for interscholastic sports. Marsh and Kleitman found that out of the eight different categories of extracurricular activities studied, only academic clubs and school publications "had a substantial number of effects that were exclusively positive, indicating that higher levels of participation in these types of activities are associated with higher outcomes" (p. 499).

Similarly, Darling et. al. found that "those who participated in non-sport ECAs reported consistently better adjustment than those who did not participate in ECAs and those who participate in sports," and furthermore, that "alcohol and marijuana use were not independently associated with ECA [extracurricular activity] participation," directly contradicting Marsh and Kleitman's findings that extracurricular activities helped preclude substance abuse (p. 51). In fact, Darling et. al. found that alcohol intake actually increased with extracurricular activity, something that will be important to remember later when considering college sports activity (p. 71-72).

Taken together, these initial results indicate that while high school level interscholastic sports provide some benefits to academic performance and personal development, other, nonathletic activities are actually better at providing these same improvements. At first glance this does not appear to be a particularly damning assessment of school sports, but one must take into account certain factors which were not accounted for in the literature but would have substantial effects on the analysis of sports' contributions to academic and personal performance.

Firstly, and perhaps most importantly as the focus of this study is largely education and academic importance, the majority of high school interscholastic sports teams have academic requirements for their players, such that any given player must maintain a certain grade point average in order to remain on the team, a stipulation not present in most other non-athletic extracurricular activities. While one might be inclined to suggest that this reflects' well on sports programs' commitment to academic excellence, in reality this results in skewed effects on academic performance, because analyses of most other extracurricular activities are pulling from a much…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Anonymous. (2008). Report finds that most black colleges are not in compliance with title

ix. The Journal of Blacks in Higher Education, 59, 20-22.

Aries, E, McCarthy, D, Salovey, P & Banaji, M (2004). A comparison of athletes and nonathletes at highly selective colleges: academic performance and personal development. Research in Higher Education, 45(6), 577-602.

Darling, N, Caldwell, L & Smith, R (2005). Participation in school-based extracurricular activities and adolescent adjustment. Journal of Leisure Research, 37(1), 51-76.


Cite this Document:

"Sports And Education While Research Has Shown" (2011, August 13) Retrieved August 4, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/sports-and-education-while-research-has-51796

"Sports And Education While Research Has Shown" 13 August 2011. Web.4 August. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/sports-and-education-while-research-has-51796>

"Sports And Education While Research Has Shown", 13 August 2011, Accessed.4 August. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/sports-and-education-while-research-has-51796

Related Documents
Education Research It Appears That the School
Words: 1001 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 27918772

Education Research It appears that the school systems are failing here in America. Every year test score trend downward as a continual new stream of information floods into the public consciousness. More schooling and more intensive schooling efforts have shown little if any progress in recent decades and before any more money or energy is thrown at these problems indiscriminately, a tactical pause to contemplate the situation seems in order. New problems

Sports Shoes Turkey Sports Shoes
Words: 8792 Length: 30 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 91958229

Turkey, clearly has a proud and longstanding history with sports and sports enthusiasm. Sports, as a cultural access point in fact is written into the Turkish constitution, as an aspect of cultural and personal growth goals for the entire nation. Turkey is one of the rare countries in the world which has an article related to sports in her Constitution. Article 59 of the Constitution says, "The State takes measures

Sports Injuries Legal Issues in
Words: 1120 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 35621129

In addition to reckless and intentional action that results in injury, amateur coaching decisions, recommendations, and strategies can lead to injuries and can be considered elements of avoidable risk, constituting a breach of duty based on the expectations of the participants (Fitzgerald 2005). Breach can also occur, of course, through the intentional or reckless behavior of sports participants that shows a disregard of the basic rules and expectations of

Education - Administration Plan for
Words: 1732 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 42681612

- in a program managed through "teacher cooperatives," which are funded by "independent organizations" (in fact commercial vendors donating to schools for tax write-off purposes and to bring positive publicity to them) - would become assigned to work in more than one school. For example, a terrific advanced physics teacher would be assigned to work in two or three high schools, mentoring other physics teachers as needed, and his

Sports Leadership and Life Skills
Words: 344 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 65031465

“It’s not whether you win or lose, but how you play the game.” Many of the most common cultural maxims are sports related, because sports great an optimal environment for social learning. Sports teach self-efficacy and build honest confidence, while also helping individuals develop the communications and leadership skills they can apply in all areas of life. In face, empirical research continually shows that participation in sports leads to life skills

Education and Gender Inequality
Words: 3250 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Sports - Women Paper #: 36185144

Gender Issues in Education Today The objective of this study is to examine gender issues in education today and to discuss its impacts or potential impacts on individuals and society. This study will examine how this issue has been addressed by philanthropy, charitable organizations, and governments. Initial examination of the gender gap in education appears to show that women are on the receiving end of less education to prepare them for life