South Asia Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 2 Subject: History - Asian Type: Essay Paper: #91933656 Related Topics: Southeast Asia, Bangladesh, Brewing, Pakistan
Excerpt from Essay :


What impact did British rule have in South Asia in the political, economic and social arenas, especially during the period of formal rule under the Crown (1857-1947)?

Social unrest, political instability and fragmentation, and economic transformations led to the dismantling of the East India Company and the instatement of Crown Rule in 1858. The period during which Crown Rule, known colloquially as the Raj, was first established was known as the Great Rebellion. It was during this time that the Crown came to realize fully the extent to which colonial activities impacted political, economic, and social arenas. The Crown had also come to reckon with the enormous diversity of culture, language, and religion in India. During the Raj, India's strategic alliances shifted according to utility and opportunity. Alliances with the Crown and rebellions against it shaped modern Indian history. British rule introduced a burgeoning capitalist market economy in India, while allowing Indian business concerns to access global markets via the Crown. The groundwork for democratic institutions through the British parliamentary system were firmly laid during the Raj as well. Social class stratification changed surprisingly little with British rule, as India proved only to be a mirror through which British social class stratification could be viewed in a unique light. However, British rule in South Asia did foment tensions between different ethnic groups and those tensions have remained unresolved more than a half century after Independence.

British Crown rule led to tremendous shifts in the social culture of the Indian subcontinent, transforming relationships between different ethnic groups. Immediately after Crown Rule began, the once-trusted Bengali Army rebelled in a highly organized mutiny. The British responded immediately with a "divide and rule" methodology that would characterize many of its social policies in addition to its military organizational strategy (Soherwordi 2). Indeed, ethnic tensions came to a head during the period of formal Crown rule, as centuries of perceived oppression under Muslim Shahs had irked Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis, and other ethnic groups. British rule provided a false and temporary colonial umbrella, but fomented tensions by favoring some ethnic groups over others. These tensions especially came to a head after Independence, throughout Partition, the creation of Bangladesh later, and the failed policies that enabled the ongoing fighting in Kashmir.

Social consequences of Raj rule boil down to race-based policies of favoritism and the cultivation of strategic alliances that would ensure political and economic stability. The insurrection of the Bengali Army in 1859 forced the British to reconsider how it formed strategic alliances with the subcontinent's various ethnic communities. Some ethnic communities were viewed as "martial races," better suited for military service (Soherwordi 2). The Sikhs of the Punjab and the Ghurkas of Nepal were among the favored "martial races." Peasants were also deemed more loyal to the Raj, or at least, more easily curried with favors like land ownership (Soherwordi). Ensuring each regimen would be diverse in terms of socio-economic class or caste, as well as ethnicity, promoted the "divide and rule" policy that was intended to prevent insurrection. The Crown was correct, and the ensuing decades strengthened the armed forces. In 1895, the military was unified into the Indian Army. Meanwhile, the British wooed Punjabi soldiers by promising them land and social status. Gaining the trust of Punjabi people meant a highly trained, efficient, loyalist military service that revealed rifts in the social fabric of the subcontinent between those who supported the Raj and those who did not. Obviously, those who supported the Raj were groups directly benefitting from British rule in economic or political ways.

The Raj transformed the economy of the subcontinent, introducing principles of industrialization, modernization, and urbanization, all of which depended on ascription to capitalism. Consequences of British colonialism and Raj rule both benefitted and harmed the economies of the subcontinent. The "divide and rule" method meant that some groups fared far better than others financially. Generally, "imperial policies did initiate a process of economic growth based on the production of goods intensive in labor and natural resources," (Roy 109). The British constructed vast, extensive, and effective transportation networks including thousands of miles of railway that remain extant and viable today. Likewise, canals and irrigation systems helped to increase farming outputs. The trade.

Yet the British did not provide the social, economic, and political institutions that would allow the subcontinent to perpetuate its burgeoning potential for prosperity. Underinvestment in schools and in public health diminished the productive capacity per worker as well as GDP (Roy). The British could not undo centuries of ingrained social class stratification or patriarchy, and these were also domestic reasons for why Raj rule failed to help the subcontinent maximize its economic potential. Chronic social unrest due to political disenfranchisement and ethnic prejudice threatened to undermine the economic growth and political stability throughout South Asia. The situation was made even tenser due to the expansion of Russian colonial interests into Central Asia, which potentially threatened British strongholds in the subcontinent. British attempts to bolster its Indian armed forces were based in part on mounting tensions in South Asia, but also those brewing in Europe.

Growing dissatisfaction with Crown rule throughout South Asia, and the global movement toward nationalist ideology, led to an inevitable independence movement that began in earnest with the formation of the Indian National Congress in 1885 (Kaul). Its post-colonial agenda was nebulous, though. The Indian National Congress had been initially organized by intellectual elites who wanted to retain many of the core structures and institutions erected by the Crown (Kaul). A schism developed within the Indian National Congress, because many members hoped for a more radical break from raj institutions. In response to the political organization of Hindus, the Muslim League was created in 1907 to help organize Muslims in the subcontinent. These two organizations highlighted the growing political tensions and budding extremism in the politics of the subcontinent. At this time, possible futures for the subcontinent included a unified regional government or the division of South Asia into multiple nation-states. The result was a weak combination of the two. India and Pakistan are both ethnically diverse and divided politically, with Muslims in India being especially weakened in the wake of Partition (Bhatti).

Initially, the Indian National Congress was fragmented and relatively disorganized, and soon became divided over levels of radical responses to how to deal with the Raj. During the First World War, India conscripted members of the Indian Army to aid their own war efforts in Europe, while in the Punjab, a massacre in Amritsar led to mounting resentment against the nature of Crown rule. When the British lost one of their previously most loyal constituent bases, the Sikh Punjabis, its tenure as political overlord had reached a certain end. Chaos and turmoil mounted as the British prepared to extricate itself from its colonies in South Asia after the Second World War. Gandhi's leadership helped unite Hindus under the rubric of nationalism, but it was a brand of nationalism that systematically excluded non-Hindu minorities. By the time the British left, South Asia was perhaps more fragmented than it had been at the commencement of commercialization.

When Independence was finally secured, it was done so in a manner that led to the violent displacement of between ten and fifteen million people between Pakistan and India (Basu; Bates). Bengal had already been partitioned based on Hindu vs. Muslim allegiances, but after Partition, it was Pakistan that was divided into East and West in spite of both segments being Muslim majority regions. Kashmir had never been agreed-upon, and both sides of the border continue to claim possession of the water-bearing and strategic piece of land there. The Sikhs had vied for their own homeland and lost, disempowering that community.

The ethnic tensions that the Crown had allowed to, and in some ways encouraged to, fester came to a head during Partition. Partition entailed the purposefully created ethnic nation-states of India and Pakistan. British power had been centered primarily in what is now India, leading to stronger economic, political, and social institutions in Delhi and Bombay and relatively weak counterparts in what is now Pakistan. Pakistan banked on an underdeveloped agrarian economy, and was unable to compete in the global market as India had been prepared to do. Muslims remaining in India also complain systematically of political oppression as political minorities, as well as lack of economic opportunities, while Indians generally mistrust Pakistan as its northern neighbor (Bhatti). Since Partition, Kashmir and other border regions have suffered from perpetual strife and violence.

Works Cited

Basu, Tanya. "The Fading Memory of South Asia's Partition."…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Basu, Tanya. "The Fading Memory of South Asia's Partition." The Atlantic. Aug 15, 2014. Retrieved online:

Bates, Crispin. "The Hidden Story of Partition and its Legacies." BBC. Mar 3, 2011. Retrieved online:

Bhatti, Tariq Hameed. "Political Legacy of the Muslims in India." Journal of Political Studies. Vol 18, No. 2, 2001, pp. 225-242.

Kaul, Chandrika. "From Empire to Independence." BBC History. Retrieved online:
Soherwordi, Syed. "Punjabisation in the British Indian Army 1857-1947." Edinburgh Papers in South Asian Studies 24(2010). Retrieved online:

Cite this Document:

"South Asia" (2014, November 20) Retrieved August 11, 2022, from

"South Asia" 20 November 2014. Web.11 August. 2022. <>

"South Asia", 20 November 2014, Accessed.11 August. 2022,

Related Documents
South Asia, With an Emphasis
Words: 672 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 39909806

The social impact of the Islamic revival, however, produced a third alternative that is both modern and firmly rooted in Islamic faith, identity, and values. Muslim women, both modernists and Islamists, have argued on Islamic grounds for an expanded role in the society (Iqbal)." In a political sense, "most of the regimes in the Islamic world are authoritarian, undemocratic and lack legitimacy. These governments must divert public attention from the

South Asia Book Review Instructions: Please Submit
Words: 1585 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 84958417

SOUTH ASIA Book Review INSTRUCTIONS: Please submit a book review Rabindranath Tagore is a South Asian novelist of considerable acclaim who won a Nobel prize for literature. In one of his more well-known works of literature, Home and the World, he demonstrates that his reputation is not only well deserved, but possibly even something of an understatement. While utilizing a variety of narrators, the author has produced an intricately woven

Asian Women South Asia Consists
Words: 3565 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Sports - Women Paper #: 93794193

The women are anticipated to spend 80% of her reproductive years in pregnancy and lactation. A latest study undertaken by the New Delhi-based Center for Science and the Environment of the small Himalayan village of Bemru revealed that child birth in majority of the instances happen in the cattle stable, as villagers consider that holy cows safeguard the mother and the newborn child from evil spirits. Childbirth is regarded

South Asian Economics the "Spatial
Words: 3152 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 64951057

This in fact creates spatial poverty traps where these previously did not exist. The areas no longer support the traditional businesses in which families engaged, and such families are obliged to become migrant laborers or to be away from their areas for extended periods of time. This in itself contributes to a lack of school attendance. Young children in a continual state of migration find it extremely hard to

South Africa Economy History of
Words: 3087 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Literature - African Paper #: 35179086

The laws of South Africa has been constituted and formed, as a result of the influence from the English laws in procedure. 6. Environmental Concerns Where it has been observed that South Africa is full of resources, on the other hand, it has also come to notice that environmental concerns also loom large as one of the issues that needs grave consideration. Amongst the environmental concerns, air pollution, marine pollution, soil

South Korea: Multilateralism, Regionalism and
Words: 4551 Length: 15 Pages Topic: History - Asian Paper #: 25066002

Certainly, this is reinforced by recent legislative efforts currently under discussion in the parliament. The ruling Grand National Party has been the subject of public resistance more recently, perhaps owing to the global economic slowdown which has caused widespread discontent throughout the world. In response, and with elections -- at that time -- approaching, the South Korean government considered the passage of legislation that would both place limitations and