Human Genome Project May Be Thesis

Length: 8 pages Sources: 8 Subject: Genetics Type: Thesis Paper: #46892228 Related Topics: Organ Transplant, Kidney Failure, Organ Donation, Down Syndrome
Excerpt from Thesis :

Since the antigens are closely linked to race and ethnicity, it is much easier to find a biological match among people with similar ethnic and racial backgrounds than it is among any two randomly selected individuals. On the basis of tissue matching, organs from blacks will almost always go to blacks and organs from whites will almost always go to whites. Blacks, however, have a much higher incidence of kidney failure than whites. But since whites significantly outnumber blacks in the American population, there are still large numbers of whites waiting for organs. There are so many, in fact, that nearly every white donor is matched to a white recipient. Blacks and other minorities must rely on a much smaller pool of kidneys. The situation for potential black kidney transplant recipients is made even worse by the fact that blacks have a lower rate of cadaver organ donation than do whites. So there is a disproportionately small share of black cadaver kidneys available for a disproportionately large group of blacks in need of kidney transplants. By deciding to use biology in the name of efficiency and, it must be added, fairness, whites wind up with a much larger number of kidney transplants than do blacks relative to the incidence of renal failure in both groups. (Caplan, p. 33-34).

The HGP can impact race in a non-medical way as well. Currently, members of ethnic groups either self-identify or are identified by others due to physical markers or characteristics. For example, in America, a dark skinned person with certain features, such as thicker lips or kinky hair, is presumed by people to be African-American and is treated like an African-American, regardless of actual genetic heritage. However, people may actually not have the genetic heritage to support an existing racial or ethnic identity, which begs the question: "Should knowledge generated by the genome project be used to identify, classify, or label racial or ethnic groups or to establish the boundaries of their membership?" (Caplan, p.40). Furthermore, if people are screened or selected for race, should genetic/biological definitions be used or will cultural and political definitions prevail? (Caplan, p.40). If genetic definitions prevail, then it is likely that people who culturally identify with certain races will be excluded from those classifications because DNA studies have not revealed classifiable races in modern humans; though some alleles are more highly identified with certain subgroups of people, some members of those subgroups will not have those alleles, and some people outside of those subgroups will have those alleles.

The largest ethical issue related to the Human Genome Project is the looming specter of human cloning. While the cloning of an entire human being may be impossible anytime in the foreseeable future, and animal clones have repeatedly had some health issues that were not present in the original animal, the idea of human cloning is more of a grey area than opponents would have one believe. After all, cloning does not have to be of an entire person. In fact, proponents of cloning rarely suggest that one should clone an entire person. On the contrary, they suggest that cloning would be appropriate to replace single failed organs, because a cloned organ would not be rejected in the way that donor organs are rejected.

Legal Concerns

One interesting legal issue is whether the state could require or, conversely, prohibit certain types of genetic testing. For example, some genetic conditions make a person far more susceptible to certain disease; should the government be allowed to require people to get those tests? It is unlikely that the government would ever require every individual to submit to random genetic testing, but there are certainly situations where other stakeholders might want to insist upon mandatory testing. For example, the costs of preventative medicine are often considerably lower than the costs of treatment. Therefore, it is imaginable that insurers might push for mandatory genetic testing, so that they could deny coverage to those who did not comply with preventative medical recommendations for certain conditions. It is conceivable, for example, that, if genetic testing were mandatory, an insurer could...


The reality is that people's insurance companies oftentimes have unfettered access to their health records. Moreover, people oftentimes are required by potential employers to waive privacy regarding their health records. The result is that some Americans are discriminated against in employment and insurance because of health conditions. When this discrimination occurs because of a manifested health condition, for example, cancer, it is a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act. However, until May 21, 2008, employers and insurers could use information from genetic testing to discriminate against their employees or customers. On May 21, 2008, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act was signed into law, and it prohibited insurance companies and employers from discriminating on the basis of information derived from genetic testing. However, like other prohibitive laws, the potential employee or insured retains the onus of proving discrimination, which can be a very difficult burden to meet. The ability to get early genetic testing without fearing negative consequences can be very important, because early detection can provide people with the opportunity to engage in preventative therapies, which may significantly delay, or even prevent, the onset of certain genetic-based diseases.


The Human Genome Project has offered unprecedented insight into human hereditary conditions, which can lead to preventative medicine saving and improving the quality of life of millions of individuals. However, that knowledge has not come without a cause. There are definite concerns associated with the project, but those concerns are not really about the Human Genome Project. The reality is that human beings have a history of ugly discrimination against people whom they perceive as alien or other.

The Human Genome Project has given that type of person another method by which to discriminate against others. However, those people would use other methods to discriminate, if given the chance. Is it not fair to assume that a person who would discriminate against a person because of genetic characteristics would also discriminate against them due to appearance? The problems associated with the Human Genome Project are not unique to that project, which is why society already has many of the tools it needs to deal with the new ways that those problems will undoubtedly manifest now that the project is complete.

Works Cited

Andrew, Lori. "Public Choices and Private Choices: Legal Regulation of Genetic Testing."

Justice and the Human Genome Project. Ed. Timothy Murphy and Marc Lappe. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1994, 46-75.

Caplan, Arthur. "Handle with Care: Race, Class, and Genetics." Justice and the Human Genome Project. Ed. Timothy Murphy and Marc Lappe. Los Angeles:

University of California Press, 1994, 30-46.

Collins, Francis, Eric Green, Alan Guttmacher, and Mark Guyer. "A Vision for the Future of Genomics Research." Nature 422 (2003), 835-847.

Kevles, Daniel. "Eugenics and the Human Genome Project: Is the Past Prologue?" Justice and the Human Genome Project. Ed. Timothy Murphy and Marc Lappe. Los Angeles:

University of California Press, 1994, 14-30.

National Human Genome Research Institute. "ELSI Research Program." 2008.

National Human Genome Research Institute. 17 Nov. 2008

Pun, Pattle. "On Ethics: Toward an Ethics of the Human Genome Project." Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 50 (1998): 164-175.

Stein, Rob. "Fresh Hopes and Concerns as Fetal DNA Tests Advance." The Washington Post.


Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Andrew, Lori. "Public Choices and Private Choices: Legal Regulation of Genetic Testing."

Justice and the Human Genome Project. Ed. Timothy Murphy and Marc Lappe. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1994, 46-75.

Caplan, Arthur. "Handle with Care: Race, Class, and Genetics." Justice and the Human Genome Project. Ed. Timothy Murphy and Marc Lappe. Los Angeles:

University of California Press, 1994, 30-46.

Cite this Document:

"Human Genome Project May Be" (2008, November 17) Retrieved October 23, 2021, from

"Human Genome Project May Be" 17 November 2008. Web.23 October. 2021. <>

"Human Genome Project May Be", 17 November 2008, Accessed.23 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Human Genome Project One of the Primary
Words: 999 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 68761414

Human Genome Project One of the primary concerns of the biological sciences today is human health. The more information is made known about the human body, the more curative and preventive steps can be taken to ensure the longevity and health of the human body. This is one of the ends of the Human Genome Project (HGP), which was concluded in 2003. The project ran for 13 years and was coordinated

Human Genome Project Hgp Was Designed to
Words: 580 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 83505800

Human Genome Project (HGP) was designed to provided detailed and complete information about the genes in human DNA. Not funded by any private corporation, the HGP will generate information that can be used by a wide variety of agencies and companies in the 21st century and beyond (Guyer & Collins, 1995). With this information, scientists can greatly improve how they perform human research, and the medical implications may have few

Human Genome Project and Its
Words: 2561 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 46535812

" The ethical concerns about the ability to obtain this information revolve around the possibility of discrimination against people who have less than superior gene pools and that those people will be shunned from society, or worse yet, rounded up and locked up before they have ever done anything wrong. In addition there is also the concern that the wealthy will be able to genetically order perfect children with the highest IQ's

The Human Genome Project Chromosome Abnormality
Words: 690 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 40638043

The Human Genome Project was the global, collaborative research program with the main purpose of completing the mapping and comprehension of all the genes of human beings. In delineation, genome encompasses all of the genes put together (National Human Genome Research Institute, 2018). The undertaking of the Human Genome Project has permitted researchers to start to comprehend the scheme and outline for building a person. With the progression and advancement

Ability to Study of Human Genome Is
Words: 745 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 20734993

ability to study of Human Genome is an important scientific discovery that posed major threats to the great ideals of human dignity, privacy and confidentially of one's medical history when it first made headlines in 1998. To fully exploit the scope of this discovery, Human Genome Project was launched that again had few supporters and numerous opponents. The general public, not aware of the deeper scientific reasons behind launching

The Human Genome Experiment and Its Implications for Health Care
Words: 1327 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Health - Public Health Issues Paper #: 94360837

The Human Genome Experiment and Its Implications for Health Care History of Medical Technology: Implications of Changes in the Theory and Practice of Medical Care Innovations in medical devices and health care technologies have generated new questions concerning the precise role that race, gender and other human differences had on the theory and practice of medical care in the 20th century and what the implications of these important trends will be going