Foundationally Promising Research Discoveries Of Term Paper

Length: 20 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Biology Type: Term Paper Paper: #95138553 Related Topics: Prohibition, Cardinal Health, Invitro Fertilization, In Vitro Fertilization
Excerpt from Term Paper :

For some the issue then arises when the pluripotent cells are removed from the blastocyst, as this very act negates the ability for the cell group to develop into a human being. "Note that the process of changing from totipotent to pluripotent to multipotent cells is not reversible -- that is, pluripotent stem cells do not produce totipotent stem cells, and multipotent stem cells do not produce pluripotent stem cells."

Borror, O'Rourke and Skirboll 54) Additionally, the proponents of stem cell work cite the pluripotent as incapable of producing a human being therefore not a destruction of life, hence leading to the Bush decision to ban the creation of new lines of stem cells, as it would require the destruction of further human totipotent cells.

Multipotent. The pluripotent stem cells undergo further specialization into multipotent stem cells, which are committed to giving rise to cells that have a particular function. Examples of this include blood stem cells that give rise to red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets; and skin stem cells that give rise to the various types of skin cells...While stem cells are extraordinarily important in early human development, multipotent stem cells are also found in children and adults. For example, consider one of the best understood stem cells, the blood stem cell. Blood stem cells reside in the bone marrow of every child and adult, and in fact, they can be found in very small numbers circulating in the blood stream. Blood stem cells perform the critical role of continually replenishing our supply of blood cells -- red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets -- throughout life. A person cannot survive without blood stem cells.

It is for this reason and others that many pro-life advocates prefer to see funding for stem cell research to move toward the use of stem cells present in the adult human rather than that of an undeveloped embryo. Many legislators, briefed in the intricacies of the basic stem cell concepts and abiding by a moralistic foundation similar to George W. Bush have opted to limit the use of the more readily available and historical sources for stem cells. The conservative then prefer to seek out legislative results that limit the use of embryonic stem cells and in their thinking force the scientific community to redirect their investigations toward the scientifically less promising and more challenging, in many ways adult stem cell research. One promising development in the issue of stem cell research is the limitation of recipient rejection in umbilical cord source blood for bone marrow transplantation, though limited offers promising solutions if the ownership of such sources can be more readily defined.

Bourque and Sugarman 65) Proponents of stem cell research on the other hand demonstrate considerable concern about the limitation of resources as the adult stem cell is already specialized and only a few specialized groups are identified and accessible.

Stem Cell Biology a Political Issue

One would believe that with the discovery of such a potentially promising line of treatment the developed and developing world would embrace the new science and begin to test and even implement its use. To some degree this has been the case, yet despite the promise of stem cell biology and the long list of potential disease cures the bioethics of stem cell biology have left much of the research and mostly its potential growth in a quagmire of political and religious debate. It seems that at the same rate that new possibilities are perceived by the scientist and clinicians in research theory and practice the number of groups and individuals raising questions about the ethics and morality of the line of research and creating statements and standards that are designed to hopefully sway the decisions of government on the issue of stem cell research.

Nelson 49) number of authoritative groups, hoping to guide both publicly and privately funded research on human embryonic stem cells, issued reports on the ethical problems involved. These bodies include the Ethics Advisory Board constituted by Geron Corporation; the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in concert with the Institute for Civil Society [1] the Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity [2] and, most recently, the National Bioethics Advisory Commission, which was established by policy implementation on issues of bioethical import. The most recent changes in council strongly lean in favor of Bush's individual morality on the issue of stem cell research and the like. "...the Bush administration dropped renowned cell biologist -- and proponent of embryonic stem-cell research -- Elizabeth Blackburn from the President's Council on Bioethics, in favor of Diana Schaub, a political scientist who believes cloning to be 'evil.'" ("To Those Who've Been") Though not a practice new to this president many scientists and researchers are clearly concerned about the stacking of the cards in favor of further limitations on research using embryonic stem cells, and many other bioethical and often controversial issues.

The American Medical Association has been historically in favor of stem cell biology research "Our AMA: (1) encourages strong public support of federal funding for research involving human pluripotent stem cells (PSC)"

Eiseman 89) As a representative of thousands of practicing physicians and research physicians the words of such an organization are paramount to the development of projects and programs that further the development of stem cell technology. The organization has a generally moderate conception of that which it deems ethical in research and development and adopts the standards associated with another influential organization, The National Bioethics Advisory Commission.

An article in the August 2, 1999, American Medical News reviewed NBAC's recommendations on human stem cell research (Gianelli, 1999). The article gave details of NBAC's final deliberations on stem cell research, relating that NBAC adopted an _intermediate_ position that an embryo merits respect as human life, but not at the level generally accorded to persons. The article highlighted several of NBAC's key recommendations, including that research involving stem cells from embryos left over from infertility treatments and research involving germ cells from aborted fetuses should be federally funded; research using embryos created solely for research purposes, through either in vitro fertilization or cloning techniques, should not be federally funded; a national review panel and public registry should be established; and proper informed consent procedures must be followed for embryo and tissue donors.

Eiseman 89)

The political pull of a very large lobbying group, the AMA is felt yet the resulting moderate response to the use of discarded embryos has not been entirely reflected in the conservative legislation detailed later in this work.

Another group of interest that has demonstrated considerable pull on the conservative side is the Coalition of Americans for Research Ethics. "The Coalition of Americans for Research Ethics, reported that scientific evidence does indicate that adult stem cells are a viable alternative."

Hentoff 19) The moralistic organization strongly asserts the ideals of the alternative federal legislation associated with many conservative legislators and many of Bush's supporters and advisors. Though funding is the demonstrative beginning for the creation of government control over the issue of the bioethics of stem cell research the resulting controversy seems to have incited legislative action to further define the legality not only of funding support but of that which is legal or illegal. The beginning step was the assertion that cloning of human cells is illegal. Some ardent proponents of stem cell biology would conclude this to be the beginning of the end of a promising line of scientific medical research while more moderate thinkers applaud the action of the federal government as a realistic step toward regulating the bioethics of this new and promising research base before it goes completely astray of the purpose of curing and treating human disease.

Stem Cell Legislation

Recent stem cell legislation lends in the favor of the conservative, as has been said before. This is likely a result of the more conservative elements in congress having the strongest moral/ethical feelings about the need to curtail the acts of scientists before what they consider amoral acts occur. This standard can be clearly seen in the language of the Human Cloning Prohibition Act of 2001

6)(A) it will be nearly impossible to ban attempts…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited" target="_blank" REL="NOFOLLOW">

Bagley, Margo A. "Patent First, Ask Questions Later: Morality and Biotechnology in Patent Law." William and Mary Law Review 45.2 (2003): 469+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005

Balestra, Dominic J. "Toward Epistemic Justice." Fordham Urban Law Journal 30.1 (2002): 47+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005

Bedford-Strohm, Heinrich. "Sacred Body? Stem Cell Research and Human Cloning." The Ecumenical Review 54.3 (2002): 240+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Berkowitz, Peter. "The Pathos of the Kass Report." Policy Review (2002): 71+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Best, Thomas F., and Martin Robra. "Editorial: The Quarterly of the World Council of Churches." The Ecumenical Review 54.3 (2002): 209+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Black, Jason Edward. "Extending the Rights of Personhood, Voice, and Life to Sensate Others: A Homology of Right to Life and Animal Rights Rhetoric." Communication Quarterly 51.3 (2003): 312+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Borror, Kristina, P. Pearl O'Rourke, and Lana Skirboll. "A Stem Cell Primer." Forum for Applied Research and Public Policy 15.1 (2000): 54. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Bourque, Jamieson, and Jeremy Sugarman. "Banking on the Future." Forum for Applied Research and Public Policy 15.1 (2000): 65. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Cohen, Cynthia B. "Protestant Perspectives on the Uses of the New Reproductive Technologies." Fordham Urban Law Journal 30.1 (2002): 135+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Cook, Corey. "The Contemporary Presidency: The Permanence of the "Permanent Campaign" George W. Bush's Public Presidency." Presidential Studies Quarterly 32.4 (2002): 753+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Dulles, Avery Cardinal. "Catholic Social Teaching and American Legal Practice." Fordham Urban Law Journal 30.1 (2002): 277+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Eiseman, Elisha. The National Bioethics Advisory Commission: Contributing to Public Policy / . Santa Monica, CA: Rand, 2003.
Elliott, E. Donald. "The Genome and the Law: Should Increased Genetic Knowledge Change the Law?." Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy 25.1 (2001): 61+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
November 3, 2004,
Fredericks, Marcel, et al. "Toward an Understanding of Cellular Sociology and Its Relationships to Cellular Biology." Education 124.2 (2003): 237+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
The Future of Stem Cell Research." The Washington Times 18 Nov. 2003: A22. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Gibelman, Margaret, and Sheldon R. Gelman. "Learning from the Mistakes of Others: A Look at Scientific Misconduct in Research." Journal of Social Work Education 37.2 (2001): 241. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Gottweis, Herbert. "Stem Cell Policies in the United States and in Germany: Between Bioethics and Regulation." Policy Studies Journal 30.4 (2002): 444+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Gribbin, August. "Nobel Laureates Push for Stem-Cell Research." The Washington Times 9 Mar. 1999: 6. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Hannafey, Francis T. "A Companion to Genethics." Theological Studies 64.3 (2003): 641+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Hentoff, Nat. "Out of This Stem Grows a Flower." The Washington Times 23 July 2001: 19. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Kaveny, M. Cathleen. "Jurisprudence and Genetics." Theological Studies 60.1 (1999): 135. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Lauerman, Lynn, ed. Science & Technology Almanac / . Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2002.
Marquis, Don. "Stem Cell Research: The Failure of Bioethics." Free Inquiry Winter 2002: 40+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Nelson, James Lindemann. "Ethics and Embryos." Forum for Applied Research and Public Policy 15.1 (2000): 49. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Pellegrino, Edmund D. "The Physician's Conscience, Conscience Clauses, and Religious Belief: A Catholic Perspective." Fordham Urban Law Journal 30.1 (2002): 221+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Pika, Joseph A. "The White House World: Transition, Organization, and Office Operations." Presidential Studies Quarterly 33.4 (2003): 945+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Rai, Arti K., and Rebecca S. Eisenberg. "Bayh-Dole Reform and the Progress of Biomedicine." Law and Contemporary Problems (2003): 289+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Reisman, W. Michael. "Unratified Treaties and Other Unperfected Acts in International Law: Constitutional Functions." Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 35.3 (2002): 729+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Republican Senators Clash at Hearing on Stem Cell Research." Issues in Science and Technology Summer 2000: 23. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Roy, Lisa Shaw. "Roe and the New Frontier." Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy 27.1 (2003): 339+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Schecter, Cliff. "Extremely Motivated: The Republican Party's March to the Right." Fordham Urban Law Journal 29.4 (2002): 1663+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Schroeder, Christopher H. "Deliberative Democracy's Attempt to Turn Politics into Law." Law and Contemporary Problems 65.3 (2002): 95+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Shannon, Thomas A. "Ethical Issues in Genetics." Theological Studies 60.1 (1999): 111. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Shannon, Thomas A. "Human Embryonic Stem Cell Therapy." Theological Studies 62.4 (2001): 811+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Shannon, Thomas A. "Remaking Ourselves? The Ethics of Stem-Cell Research." Commonweal 4 Dec. 1998: 9. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Smith, Wesley J. The Assault on Medical Ethics in America. San Francisco, CA: Encounter Books, 2000.
Sosnowski, Kristie. "Genetic Research: Are More Limitations Needed in the Field?." Journal of Law and Health 15.1 (2000): 121+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Stevens, Denise. "Embryonic Stem Cell Research: Will President Bush's Limitation on Federal Funding Put the United States at a Disadvantage? A Comparison between U.S. And International Law." Houston Journal of International Law 25.3 (2003): 623+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
To Those Who've Been Keeping Track at Home, It Was No Surprise When the Bush Administration Dropped Renowned Cell Biologist -- And Proponent of Embryonic Stem-Cell Research-Elizabeth Blackburn from the President's Council on Bioethics in Favor of Diana Schaub, a Political Scientist Who Believes Cloning to Be "Evil.." Washington Monthly Apr. 2004: 14+. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Wright, Shirley J. "Human Embryonic Stem-Cell Research: Science and Ethics." American Scientist July-Aug. 1999: 352. Questia. 17 Jan. 2005
Expressing the sense of the Congress supporting Federal funding of pluripotent stem cell research.

Cite this Document:

"Foundationally Promising Research Discoveries Of" (2005, January 17) Retrieved November 29, 2022, from

"Foundationally Promising Research Discoveries Of" 17 January 2005. Web.29 November. 2022. <>

"Foundationally Promising Research Discoveries Of", 17 January 2005, Accessed.29 November. 2022,

Related Documents
HPV Vaccination According to the
Words: 2106 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 80223087 In 2006, an estimated 9,710 cases of invasive cervical cancer will be diagnosed in the United States, and an estimated 3,700 women will die from this disease. Globally, cervical cancer is the second most common cause of cancer death in women, with an estimated 510,000 newly diagnosed cervical cancer cases and 288,000 deaths." Saslow, 2007, at HPV is arguably the most common sexually transmitted disease in the United States,