Legalizing Abortion Term Paper

Length: 10 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Women's Issues - Abortion Type: Term Paper Paper: #53134316 Related Topics: Roe V Wade, Against Abortion, Medieval Woman, Pro Choice Abortion

Excerpt from Term Paper :

DEFENDING a WOMEN'S RIGHT TO CHOOSE ABORTION Abortion, or the elective termination of pregnancy likely predates recorded human history, being practiced within virtually every society throughout the world.(6)

In 1973, the United States Supreme Court very specifically decided that the United

States Constitution affords a fundamental right to individual privacy that absolutely prohibits governmental interference with a women's autonomous right to seek medical termination of unwanted pregnancy, except where deemed necessary to safeguard the woman's health paternalistically.(4) Ever since the legal issue was decided by the Supreme Court in 1973, a so-called pro-life lobby, spearheaded by religious opposition to any type of abortion has campaigned for and funded the proposition of legislation and policies designed to undermine the rights recognized and established under constitutional law in the United States.

Ultimately, the United States Constitution requires that the appropriate guidelines for defining legally permissible abortion rights and relative concern for the rights and feelings of the fetus be found in objective concepts of morality and medical science, rather than in religious teachings.

Background and History:

In the American Colonies, abortion was allowed until the point known under British common law as quickening when the fetus could be felt moving inside the womb. Prior to the nineteenth century, abortions were performed completely without regulation in the United States because the title "Medical Doctor" could be claimed at will, by anybody. During the eighteenth century, approximately half the American states enacted laws prohibiting abortions to some degree, and by the turn of the nineteenth century, the recently formed American Medical Association had succeeded in obtaining laws prohibiting abortions performed by anyone other than a Medical

Doctor licensed by the AMA. In many respects, this amounted to the utter inability of women to control their own bodies, since properly accredited medical schools did not yet admit female students.(6)

Some state statutes banned all abortions outright until 1973 when the United

States Supreme court decided Roe v. Wade, finding that such statutes were unconstitutionally restrictive of a woman's privacy rights. Under The Roe decision, states may not interfere with a woman's right to obtain a medical abortion during the first trimester of pregnancy, but they may impose certain restrictions based on considerations of the woman's health during the second trimester. Third trimester abortions may be prohibited by statute except where medically necessary for the safety of the mother.(4)

Since 1973, a politically powerful pro-life lobby funded by the religious Right has instigated a steady stream of statutes designed to undermine Roe, most recently in 2000, when the Supreme Court decided in Stenberg v. Carhart that a Nebraska statute banning so-called "partial birth abortion" procedures violated Roe. In 2003, President

George W. Bush signed the federal Partial Birth Abortion Act, that is virtually identical to the Nebraska law struck down by the Supreme Court in 2000.(3)

At the present time, federal judges in Nebraska, San Francisco and New York have prevented the law from taking effect by granting injunctive relief while entertaining legal arguments in three separate federal lawsuits ongoing as of this writing. At issue is the over breadth of a law which would effectively ban abortions across the country as early as thirteen weeks, because it prohibits standard medical procedures necessary in the vast majority of abortions performed during the second trimester, notwithstanding Roe.(8)

The Argument Against Abortion:

The only modern argument against abortion rests on the religious definition of human "life" as something that begins at conception. According to this particular view, God bestows life, and therefore a human soul upon an individual at the instant that a single human sperm cell fertilizes a human ovum. The religious position defines all abortion as the murder of a human being. The most extreme proponents of this point-of-view advocate murdering doctors who perform abortions because they consider health care providers working in abortion clinics to be mass murderers of innocent human beings.

According to the statement issued on the thirtieth anniversary of Roe v. Wade by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops:

Roe v. Wade has left a trail of broken hearts...we will continue to help the broken-hearted...These are the converted hearts that will at last bring an end to abortion...Roe v....


Wade cannot stand as the law of this great nation, a nation founded on the self-evident truth that all people are created with an inalienable right to life. We are committed, no matter how long it may take, no matter the sacrifices required, to bringing about a reversal of this tragic Supreme Court decision. We will speak out on behalf of the sanctity of each and every human life wherever it is threatened, from conception to natural death, and we urge all people of good will to do likewise. For, as Pope John Paul II reminds us, "it is impossible to further the common good without acknowledging and defending the right to life, upon which all the other inalienable rights of individuals are founded and from which they develop... Roe v. Wade must be reversed."(10) Legal Analysis:

The separation of church and state is one of the most fundamental of all philosophical concepts underlying the structure of the United States government and its relationship to American citizens. It is formally expressed in the Second

Amendment to the United States Constitution, according to which: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." (4)

As far as the issue of abortion under the laws of the United States, the Second

Amendment specifically prohibits incorporating any definitions or assumptions (such as of the definition of life) that have their origin in religious teachings or beliefs. This is precisely what is so offensive about the religious Right in general, and President

George W. Bush's attempts to interject his Christian morals into federal legislation, in particular. Many Americans subscribe to different religious beliefs about where human life begins, (7) and they have a constitutional right not to be subjected to laws reflecting Christian religious views. The Partial Birth Abortion Act of 2003 would erode women's rights to make autonomous choices granted by the Constitution and specifically defined with respect to abortion by the Supreme Court in 1973.

This is not to suggest the absence of any moral issues in establishing morally appropriate guidelines for when a pregnancy is too advanced to allow elective termination. Even the most strident supporters of the pro-choice position recognize that a woman's right to privacy and autonomy are not absolute in this regard. There are fundamental developments between the first month of human gestation and the ninth month and it is, in principle, simply a medical determination of where in between those two extremes, a fetus first becomes remotely recognizable as a living being capable of having rights for the state to protect.(9)

The point is that determination of the stage of human gestation where a fetus is entitled to humane consideration and to protection by the United States government under law must be exclusive matters of science and objective moral concern (such as for the prevention of suffering by a sentient), and may not reflect religious beliefs or philosophy.

Scientific Analysis:

Sexual reproduction -- whereby each of two progenitors contributes half the genetic makeup of the next generation of organism -- is the most common method of reproduction shared throughout the animal kingdom. Some animals manage with asexual forms of reproduction, but usually a male organism fertilizes biologically inert egg cells which begin replicating until one cell evolves into a complex organism comprising trillions of individual cells.(9)

In any case, a recently fertilized human embryo is conceptually indistinguishable in complexity, or any more "alive" than are the individual component sperm and ovum immediately prior to conception. Each represents the potential for becoming half a human life, if and only if myriad conditions are properly met, but its potential for life is zero, by itself.(5) As many as three quarters of all pregnancies are spontaneously aborted when the fertilized egg is expelled too soon to be detected as a pregnancy.(9) fertilized zygote is merely capable of beginning a long, complicated process that (sometimes) culminates in a human being. In the early embryonic stage, the developing tissues have absolutely no ability to perceive stimuli in any medium, much less to continue developing into a living, sensing human being, on their own. Modern scientific understanding of exactly how (and precisely when) certain cells migrate to form a proto brain imposes absolute limits on the earliest possible stage of gestation where a functioning "life," whether human or otherwise, exists.(5)

The earliest brainwaves in developing fetuses only begin toward the beginning of the third trimester, and prior to the end of the second trimester, no brainwaves and no perception of stimuli is biologically possible because the requisite neural architecture remains unformed.(9)

Moral Analysis:

The irony of the pro-life position is that it is anti-human and profoundly inhumane in principle. It ignores any consideration of the quality of life of unwanted children raised by reluctant, disinterested, unqualified, and sometimes…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

1. Abrams, Natalie and Buckner, Michael D. Medical Ethics: A Clinical Textbook and Reference for the Health Care Professionals.

Cambridge: MIT Press, 1983

2. Bronowski, Jacob. Science and Human Values.

New York: Harper & Row, 1965
3. Center for Reproductive Rights (Jan 2003) Roe v. Wade: Then and Now Accessed April 3, 2004 at
Accessed April 5, 2004 at
9. Sagan, Carl and Druyen, Ann. The Question of Abortion: A Search for Answers. Accessed April 2, 2004 at (
Statement of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops on the Thirtieth Anniversary of Roe v. Wade. Accessed April 1, 2004 at

Cite this Document:

"Legalizing Abortion" (2004, April 06) Retrieved June 7, 2023, from

"Legalizing Abortion" 06 April 2004. Web.7 June. 2023. <>

"Legalizing Abortion", 06 April 2004, Accessed.7 June. 2023,

Related Documents
Abortion and the Significance Towards Women's Health With Evidence...
Words: 1450 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 69294234

Abortion and the Significance Towards Women's Health With Evidence Induced abortion represents a multifaceted ethical, moral, biological, psychological, and legal human issue. The complex issue of induced abortion has been the source of substantial debate, controversy, and activism over the course of several decades. Induced abortion is medically defined as the removal or expulsion of a fetus or embryo before the fetus is able to survive outside of the uterus (Grimes

Abortion in the United States
Words: 3428 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 18059991

They argue that the fetus only has the potential of developing into a full-fledged human being; in the same way as an acorn has the potential of developing into an oak tree. In their view it is as ludicrous to call an embryo an independent human being as it would be to call an acorn an oak tree. (Lewis, 2000) Right of Woman Over Her Body The main "pro-choice" argument is

Abortion Issues
Words: 1544 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 79511714

Abortion Debate With the growing awareness regarding gender roles and their due rights, the number of misunderstandings and misapprehensions has also considerably augmented. Abortion, by some is considered the right of a woman or of the parents of the unborn child, by some a crime and by many others a debatable and a highly controversial issue. However, it has been observed that the underlying aspects of the issue under consideration are

Abortion a Modest Proposal: Abortion for Two
Words: 870 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 2934745

Abortion A Modest Proposal: Abortion for Two Perhaps the most significant debate of recent decades on a political, religious, and social level is that of abortion. Many questions are raised about whether this is a justified right inherent to any fertile woman, or an inhumane practice fostered by a barbaric society. Those who believe it is not right to abort the unborn struggle to make it as difficult as possible for anyone

Abortion and Religion Church and Abortion Debate
Words: 1402 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 71457235

Abortion and Religion Church and abortion debate Abortion has been a major issue of discussion with different group finding themselves caught up in a sensitive argument that they have to take a position. Religious groups have been vocal on condemning abortion, however there are other groups which hold that it should not just be viewed in that manner without looking the circumstances that makes one to abort and they see nothing wrong

Abortion in Politics
Words: 2649 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 53647740

Abortion in Politics The argument on legality of abortion is nurtured deep into root of American society. The judgment on Roe v. Wade where abortion became legal to today's politics. This paper analyses in depth the issue surrounding this subject and present solutions and considerations. The struggle for sexual rights has been linked to the process of building citizenship and has been challenged mainly by entrenched conservative groups like Parents' groups, or