Department Of Health And Human Thesis

Length: 10 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Disease Type: Thesis Paper: #58176948 Related Topics: Food Pyramid, Ebola Virus, Fire Department, Sars
Excerpt from Thesis :

In 2002, "President Bush signed into law the Public Health Security and Bioterrorism Preparedness and Response Act of 2002, which, among other things, eliminated the need to convene an advisory committee to amend the list of diseases" listed as quarantineable (Misrahi, Foster, Shaw, & Cetron 2004).

This law became significant during the SARS scare. Before 2002 "the list of federal quarantinable diseases in the United States had not been revised since 1983. It included cholera, diphtheria, infectious tuberculosis, plague, smallpox, yellow fever, and viral hemorrhagic fevers such as Marburg, Ebola, and Congo-Crimean" fevers (Misrahi, Foster, Shaw, & Cetron 2004). The CDC was able to quickly ad SARS to the list. In the past, the CDC "generally deferred to state and local health restrict the movement of persons within their boundaries" with such diseases (Misrahi, Foster, Shaw, & Cetron 2004). Its greater legislative ability to move quickly in classifying the illness as requiring extraordinary measures to quarantine individuals or exclude them from entry into the country was cited as a reason SARS did not reach the proportions it did in the Far East. Additionally, a comment that a "lesson learned from the outbreak is that federal, state, and local officials will have to work closely in coordinating quarantine actions at all levels of government" with HHS departments might behoove the HHS to heed in other areas of its operation such as the FDA's issuance of dietary guidelines (Misrahi, Foster, Shaw, & Cetron 2004).

A further agency under the control of the HHS is the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. This Agency works with states and other federal agencies, to prevent exposure to hazardous substances from waste sites, often in conjunction with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Yet again, the extent to which human health is affected by substances produced by powerful corporations and the burning of fossil fuels and global warming may embroil aspects of HHS's auspices in controversy, especially when it is in conjunction with other agencies (Definition of HHS, 2008, Medicine Net)..

Another part of the HHS that has been the subject of recent debate is that of the Health Resources and Services Administration -- HRSA helps provide health resources for medically underserved populations (additionally the Indian Health Service provides a similar array of social services and cares to individuals in need of Native American ancestry). Issues pertaining to sexuality are often affected in this aspect of the HHS's work. For example, quite recently the Bush Administration issued a statement that expanded the ability of health care workers, hospitals, and health insurance companies to refuse to provide health services for "sincere religious belief or moral convictions" (DeNoon 2008). HHS issued the press statement which defended the new policy covering an estimated 571,947 health provision entities including doctors' offices, pharmacies, hospitals, insurers, medical and nursing schools, diagnostic labs, nursing homes, and state governments agencies that provide health care.

The Bush Administration, an admitted foe of abortion, was viewed by many women's groups as using the policy to limit the reproductive right of choice. Even the American Medical Association decried the new Bush law noting that it: "expands the range of health care institutions and individuals who may refuse to provide services, and broadens the scope... beyond the actual provision of health care services to information and counseling about health services as well as referrals" (DeNoon 2008). The American Medical Association AMA was also worried that the new protections were so broad in terms of who was defined as a health care provider that receptionists could refuse to schedule patients for medically necessary services, and people who "clean or maintain equipment or rooms" could interrupt patient care if they claimed the treatment went against their conscience (DeNoon 2008). To repeal the rule, the incoming Obama administration could act on its own, or Congress could take the initiative pass a law repealing the rule. Regardless, this is an illustration of how the policy of the HHS is affected, some would say, tainted with politics. The FDA in the past was subject to similar political


Take even the seemingly noncontroversial subject of breast-feeding babies. In 2004, HHS was pressured to end its advertising campaign warning that not breastfeeding could hurt a newborn's health. "It featured striking photos of insulin syringes and asthma inhalers topped with rubber nipples," implying that not breast-feeding is linked to babies that are more likely to develop obesity and Type II Diabetes as well as asthma later in life (Kaufman & Lee, 2008, p.1). "Plans to run these blunt ads infuriated the politically powerful infant formula industry, which hired a former chairman of the Republican National Committee and a former top regulatory official to lobby the Health and Human Services Department. Not long afterward, department political appointees toned down the campaign" (Kaufman & Lee, 2008, p.1). The formula industry's influence to change the advertisement's content eventually subjected HHS to scrutiny by Congress, which felt that the "administration repeatedly allowed political considerations to interfere with his efforts to promote public health" (Kaufman & Lee, 2008, p.1). The "campaign HHS used did not simply drop the disputed statistics in the draft ads. The initial idea was to startle women with images starkly warning that babies could become ill. Instead, the final ads cited how breast-feeding benefits babies -- an approach that the ad company hired by HHS had advised would be ineffective. The department also pulled back on several related promotional efforts" (Kaufman & Lee, 2008, p.1).

But HHS has been subjected to criticism by advocates of mothers as well as the formula industry regarding its advocacy of breast-feeding. For example, breast-feeding advocates lobbied an end to hospitals giving free formula to new mothers upon leaving the hospital, fearing that mothers might be more apt try the formula during a "rough patch" if the baby was not feeding properly or the mother found breastfeeding painful. They feared the practice of giving formula confused mothers (Samuels 2006). HHS agreed and said that "hospital distribution of formula could unduly influence a mothers' decision to breastfeed for as long as possible" and urged hospitals to cease the practice (Samuels 2006). However, many women, particularly poor women may have difficulty producing enough milk to nourish their children or may need to go back to work quickly for economic reasons and cannot breast-feed. Pressuring hospitals to discourage women who intend to use formula to seek appropriate advice in how much to give or what kind to select may be more harmful in the long run, even if breast-feeding is 'best' for women capable of doing so.

A public health conundrum at the heart of HHS policy also relates to the question of legal and illegal drug abuse. Is drug abuse an illness or a crime? While certain aspects of the government view drug abuse solely as a crime, within HHS there is a department known as the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) that works to improve the quality and availability of substance abuse prevention, addiction treatment, and mental health services (Definition of HHS, 2008, Medicine Net).

Finally, under the reach of the HHS is the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research. "AHCPR supports cost-cutting research on health care systems, health care quality and cost issues, and effectiveness of medical treatments" (Definition of HHS, 2008, Medicine Net). Again, political allegations regarding the pressure of outside interest, specifically insurance companies, have tainted the reputation of this agency. "The U.S. government and private insurers are becoming more resistant to paying for "never events" -- avoidable accidents, errors, and conditions, including health care-associated infections" such as those caused by improper hand-washing (Mika, 2008, p. 2495). "The Government Accountability Office (GAO) released a report critical of the leadership of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in its efforts to reduce the number of health care-associated infections. Both actions came while private insurers were announcing lists of never events for which they will not reimburse hospitals" (Mika, 2008, p. 2495). Refusing to reimburse hospitals for such expenses can have serious public health consequences, as the number of strains of antibiotic-resistant bacteria is on the rise, particularly in hospitals, as are populations such as the elderly which are at greater risk because of their compromised immune systems.

To envision a future for the HHS that is untainted by politics is unrealistic, given that it is lead by a presidential appointment, and…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Definition of HHS. (2008). Medicine Net. Retrieved January 2, 2009 at

DeNoon, Daniel. (2008). Controversy over new 'conscience' rule. Medicine Net.

Retrieved January 2, 2009 at

Dowshen, Steven. (2008, August). CDC: Measles outbreaks may be tied to parents' choice not to vaccinate. The Children's Hospital. Retrieved January 2, 2009 at
Institute for Science in Society (ISIS) Press Release. Retrieved January 3, 2009 at
Johnsen, Michael. (2006, September 11) FDA approves dual-label Plan B. amid swirl of political controversy. Drug Store News.. Retrieved January 3, 2009 at
The Washington Post. Retrieved January 3, 2009 at
Retrieved January 3, 2009 at
Retrieved January 3, 2009 at
Women's e-News. Retrieved January 2, 2009 at

Cite this Document:

"Department Of Health And Human" (2009, January 03) Retrieved December 9, 2021, from

"Department Of Health And Human" 03 January 2009. Web.9 December. 2021. <>

"Department Of Health And Human", 03 January 2009, Accessed.9 December. 2021,

Related Documents
FY2012 President's Budget for Health Human Services
Words: 1158 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 31081331

FY2012 President's Budget For Health Human Services One of the most prominent roles of the federal government in health care is as a purchaser of health insurance and third-party payer for health care. The federal government serves in this capacity for almost forty million elderly and disabled persons, nine million federal government employees and their dependants, and six million active members of the military and their families. It finances, in combination

National Institutes of Health Human
Words: 2213 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 90498392

The NIH also utilizes existing technology to a great degree in their human resource strategy. This choice reflects a desire to embrace an entirely new resource base. Moreover, it may lead to a new set of data mining that will actually facilitate a previously unknown human resource knowledge base (Bernik, Florjancic, Crnigoj, & Bernik, 2007). The NIH Office of Human Resources utilizes not only their professional strategists; they also embrace

Health Politics "What Is the Role of
Words: 3149 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 37669681

Health Politics "What is the role of Congress in policy making process"? Policy is a plan to identify goal or possible course of actions with administrative or management tools to accomplish these goals. On the other hand, policy is the authoritative decision made by the U.S. executive, legislative, judicial branch of government to influence the decision of others. Government is a key player in decision-making process and congress plays important roles in

Human Resource Planning All Organizations
Words: 2145 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 94955666

For most jobs the required abilities of the employees are in terms of communication skills, motivation that is within the individual, the determination of high standards of work for himself and others, the capacity to convince others about oneself and ideas, the capacity to become future leaders, the capacity to make decisions, the ability to judge other and the base of the knowledge or technical skills possessed by the

Health Care Reform Has Been
Words: 1375 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 79622410

Despite of the receipt of federal funding to assist in the set-up of an insurance exchange program, the Minnesota legislature is not cooperating with the Governor Drayton's plans to design a program. Instead, in a classic example of partisan politics, the legislature is going forward with its own plans to design an exchange program. In doing so, the legislature is placing the State of Minnesota in a position of possibly

Health Care Services for Myocardial Infarction: Myocardial
Words: 2008 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 93325634

Health Care Services for Myocardial Infarction: Myocardial Infarction (MI) is commonly known as Acute Myocardial Infarction (AMI) is a heart attack disease in which blood supply to a part of the heart is interrupted resulting in ultimate irreversible damage and cell death in that part of the heart (Khan, 2010). As one of cardiovascular diseases, myocardial infarction can be regarded as one of the leading causes of death for men